The Short Version
Bullymake ($31-39/mo) is the toughest - solid nylon and rubber, made in USA. Super Chewer ($29-45/mo) is the best value with more variety and a free replacement guarantee. Both will replace destroyed toys for free. If your dog destroys Bullymake toys, nothing will survive.
The 5-Level Durability Scale
Not all "durable" toys are created equal. Here's how toy materials actually stack up against real power chewers.
Level 1 - Gentle
Plush toys, light fabric. Lasts minutes with a power chewer.
Materials: Plush, felt, thin rope
Level 2 - Standard
Regular rubber and nylon. Fine for most dogs, not enough for chewers.
Materials: Hollow rubber, tennis balls
Level 3 - Tough
Reinforced rubber and thick nylon. Works for moderate chewers.
Materials: Kong Classic, braided rope
Level 4 - Super Tough
Solid rubber, no hollow cavities. What Super Chewer & Bullymake use.
Materials: Solid natural rubber, reinforced nylon
Level 5 - Indestructible
Solid nylon, industrial rubber. Virtually impossible to destroy.
Materials: FDA nylon, vulcanized rubber
Bite Force & Box Recommendations by Breed
Bite force alone doesn't determine destructiveness - chewing motivation matters too. A bored Lab can destroy more than a lazy Mastiff. Use this as a starting guide.
| Breed | Bite Force | Destroy Level | Best Box |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pit Bull | 235 PSI | Extreme | Bullymake |
| Rottweiler | 328 PSI | Extreme | Bullymake |
| German Shepherd | 238 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| Labrador Retriever | 230 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| Boxer | 230 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| Mastiff | 552 PSI | Extreme | Bullymake |
| Doberman Pinscher | 245 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| Siberian Husky | 320 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| Belgian Malinois | 195 PSI | Heavy | Super Chewer |
| American Bulldog | 305 PSI | Extreme | Bullymake |
Safety Rules for Power Chewers
Even the toughest toys need supervision. Follow these rules to keep your dog safe.
Always supervise first use - watch how your dog interacts with new toys before leaving them alone
Inspect toys weekly - replace immediately if you see cracks, missing chunks, or sharp edges
Size up, not down - a toy should never fit entirely inside your dog's mouth
The thumbnail test: if you can't indent it with your thumbnail, it may damage teeth
Remove toys if your dog breaks off pieces and tries to swallow them
Rotate toys to prevent obsessive chewing on a single worn-down toy
For more toy recommendations see our power chewer toys guide.
Our Top Picks for Aggressive Chewers
Ranked by actual toy durability, replacement policy, and real-world testing with power chewers.
Super Chewer
Tough toys for power chewers
- ✓Extremely durable toys
- ✓Replacement guarantee
Bullymake
Indestructible toys monthly
- ✓Extremely tough toys
- ✓Made in USA
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best box for dogs that destroy everything?
For the absolute toughest chewers, Bullymake is the top pick. Their toys are made from solid nylon and rubber, manufactured in the USA. Super Chewer by BarkBox is a close second with a great durability guarantee. Both will replace any toy your dog manages to destroy.
Super Chewer vs Bullymake - which is better?
Bullymake toys are slightly tougher (solid nylon and rubber), making it better for the most extreme destroyers like Rottweilers and Mastiffs. Super Chewer offers better variety with themed boxes and more treat options. If your dog destroys Bullymake toys, virtually nothing will work.
Are these toys safe for aggressive chewers?
Yes, when sized correctly. Both services use non-toxic, BPA-free materials. Super Chewer uses tough rubber and nylon; Bullymake uses FDA-compliant nylon and rubber. Inspect toys regularly and replace when worn. Never give a toy too small for your dog.
Will regular BarkBox work for my aggressive chewer?
Probably not. Standard BarkBox toys include plush and fabric toys that aggressive chewers will shred immediately. Super Chewer is BarkBox's specific line for tough chewers - same fun themes but with solid rubber and nylon toys instead.
My small dog is an aggressive chewer - what box should I get?
Both Super Chewer and Bullymake offer small dog sizes. When signing up, specify your dog's weight AND that they're a heavy chewer. You'll get smaller but equally durable toys made from the same tough materials.
Do these boxes include replacement guarantees?
Yes! Super Chewer's durability guarantee replaces any toy destroyed within the month for free. Bullymake offers replacements if your dog destroys a toy. Just email photos and they'll send new ones. This is genuinely the biggest selling point.
Related Articles
Top Shih Tzu Treats And Chews For 2026
Discover the 2026 top-rated treats and chews perfect for your Shih Tzu's health and happiness.
Top Treats And Chews For Great Danes 2026
Discover the 2026 top-rated treats and chews, specially selected for your gentle giant's health and happiness.
Top Doberman Treats And Chews For 2026
Unleash 2026's top chews for your Doberman, built for powerful jaws and optimal health.
2026's Best Boxer Treats And Chews
Discover the 2026 top picks for durable treats and safe chews perfect for your Boxer's powerful jaws.
Done Wasting Money on Toys That Don't Last?
With replacement guarantees, you only pay for toys that survive. Compare your options.