Bullymake
Indestructible toys monthly
How We Score
Bullymake creates custom boxes for power chewers featuring extremely durable toys made from rubber, nylon, and ballistic materials, plus tough treats.
Price
$27-$39
Founded
2014
Reviews
18,000+
Location
Madison, WI
✓ Pros
- • Extremely tough toys
- • Made in USA
- • Customizable box contents
- • Replacement guarantee
✗ Cons
- • Limited theme variety
- • Toys only for power chewers
What Reddit Says
Based on 20 community discussions
"Reddit's sentiment toward Bullymake is mixed, with some users praising its durability for power chewers, while others criticize its value, cancellation issues, and inconsistent toy quality."
Community Praises
✓ Designed for power chewers, with some toys lasting longer than regular options
✓ Convenient subscription model for dog owners
✓ Offers a variety of tough toys in each box
Common Complaints
✗ Toys often don't live up to durability claims for aggressive chewers
✗ Poor customer service, especially regarding cancellations
✗ Expensive for the quality and longevity of the toys provided
What's Included
Shipping: Free shipping in USA
Ready to Try Bullymake?
Visit Bullymake →Quick Comparison
| Company | Price | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bullymake ⭐ | $27-$39 | 6.2 | |
| Bark Bright | $25-$35 | 6.5 | Compare |
| BoxDog | $25-$39 | 6.1 | Compare |
| Farm Hounds | $25-$45 | 6.4 | Compare |
Industry Recognition
Mentioned in 8 industry reviews and lists
Best For These Breeds
Labrador Retriever
Large, high-energy chewers need durable USA-made toys.
Golden Retriever
Strong chewers benefit from tough, ballistic-material toys.
German Shepherd
Very-high activity demands ultra-durable, long-lasting toys.
Bulldog
Customizable treats suit their lower activity needs.
Poodle
Medium-sized but active, enjoys tough, engaging toys.
Rottweiler
Powerful chewers thrive with heavy-duty, USA-made toys.
Compare Bullymake
See how Bullymake compares to similar subscription boxes.
View all 39 comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Bullymake
Is Bullymake worth it in 2026?
Bullymake scored 6.2/10 in our analysis. Key strengths include Extremely tough toys, Made in USA. The main downside is: limited theme variety. It's a decent option for most dog owners.
How much does Bullymake cost?
Bullymake costs $27 to $39 per month, depending on your dog's size and subscription length. Longer commitments typically offer better per-month pricing.
What does Bullymake include?
Each Bullymake box includes: 2-3 tough toys, 3 treat bags. Contents may vary by plan and dog size.
What dog sizes does Bullymake support?
Bullymake caters to medium, large dogs. Toy sizes and treat quantities are adjusted based on your dog's size profile.
Can you cancel Bullymake?
Yes, you can cancel Bullymake at any time through your account settings. Monthly plans can be cancelled before the next billing cycle. Multi-month plans may have different cancellation terms.