The Short Version
BarkBox ($23-35/mo) is the best all-around choice for medium dogs - you get the widest toy variety and perfectly proportioned treats. For moderate-to-heavy chewers, Super Chewer ($29-45/mo) upgrades to tougher toys with a free replacement guarantee. High-energy medium breeds love the puzzle toys and enrichment in Kong Box.
Why Medium Dogs Get the Best Deal
Here's something most people don't realize: subscription boxes are designed around medium-sized dogs. A Border Collie or Beagle gets the "standard" experience - no compromises on sizing up or down.
The Sweet Spot
Best ValueMost subscription boxes are literally designed around medium-sized dogs. You get the widest toy selection, best-fitting chews, and properly portioned treats without any compromises.
Versatile Activity Level
Most OptionsMedium dogs range from couch-loving Bulldogs to high-energy Border Collies. The best boxes let you customize by energy level and chewing style, not just weight.
Health Balance
Fewer ConcernsMedium breeds generally have fewer size-related health issues than small or large breeds. Fewer joint problems than giants, fewer dental issues than toys. Choose treats for enjoyment, not just therapy.
Toy Durability Range
Full RangeMedium dogs can handle both plush toys (for gentle chewers) and tougher rubber options (for moderate chewers). You have the full spectrum of toy types available.
20-50
Pound range
6-8"
Ideal toy size
500-1K
Daily calories
Medium Breed Subscription Guide
Medium breeds are the most varied group - from couch-potato Bulldogs to tireless Australian Shepherds. Your dog's energy level and chewing style matter more than their weight. Need help with nutrition? Check our calorie calculator.
| Breed | Weight | Energy | Chew Style | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Border Collie | 30-45 lbs | Very High | Moderate-Heavy | Puzzle toys + training treats |
| Beagle | 20-30 lbs | High | Moderate | Scent-based toys + treats |
| Australian Shepherd | 40-65 lbs | Very High | Heavy | Durable toys + chews |
| English Bulldog | 40-50 lbs | Low | Moderate | Soft toys + gentle chews |
| Cocker Spaniel | 20-30 lbs | Moderate | Light | Plush toys + soft treats |
| Corgi | 25-30 lbs | High | Moderate | Tug toys + training treats |
| Staffordshire Terrier | 24-38 lbs | High | Very Heavy | Power chewer box |
| Brittany | 30-40 lbs | Very High | Moderate | Fetch toys + high-protein treats |
| Shetland Sheepdog | 15-25 lbs | High | Light | Puzzle toys + enrichment |
| Whippet | 25-40 lbs | Moderate | Light | Soft toys + plush |
Our Top Picks for Medium Dogs
Evaluated on toy variety, treat quality, customization options, and value for medium-sized dogs.
BarkBox
Monthly surprises for your pup
- ✓Unique themed toys every month
- ✓High-quality natural treats
Super Chewer
Tough toys for power chewers
- ✓Extremely durable toys
- ✓Replacement guarantee
Frequently Asked Questions
What size dog is considered medium?
Medium dogs typically weigh 20-50 lbs and stand 15-22 inches tall. Popular medium breeds include Border Collies (30-45 lbs), Beagles (20-30 lbs), Australian Shepherds (40-65 lbs), Bulldogs (40-50 lbs), and Cocker Spaniels (20-30 lbs).
Do subscription boxes have a medium dog option?
All major services offer medium-sized options. During signup, you specify your dog's exact weight and get toys, treats, and chews sized appropriately. Most services have a "medium" tier separate from small and large.
Are medium dog boxes good value?
Medium dogs often get the best value from subscription boxes since most companies design their "standard" box around this size range. You get properly sized everything without paying extra for oversized items.
My medium dog is a power chewer - what should I get?
Medium dogs can have surprisingly strong jaws! Border Collies, Australian Shepherds, and Aussie Cattle Dogs are often aggressive chewers. Super Chewer and Bullymake both offer medium-sized durable toys.
What treats are right for a medium dog?
Medium dogs (20-50 lbs) typically need 500-1,000 calories per day. Standard-sized treats work perfectly. Look for treats in the 5-15 calorie range so you can use several for training without overdoing it.
Can I get a medium dog box with grain-free treats?
Yes! Most subscription services allow you to specify dietary preferences and allergies. BarkBox, for example, lets you exclude chicken, beef, or specific grains. For allergy-specific boxes, see our allergies guide.
Related Articles
2026 Best Treats And Chews For Beagles
Uncover the 2026 best chews for your Beagle, chosen for safety, durability, and irresistible taste.
2026's Top Beagle Subscription Box Picks
Unleash joy for your Beagle in 2026 with the ultimate subscription box, curated for their unique scent-loving, playful nature.
2026's Top Fresh Food For Beagles
Discover the top-rated fresh dog food formulas tailored to your beagle's unique energy and nutritional needs for 2026.
Find the Perfect Box for Your Medium Dog
Medium dogs get the widest selection. Compare services side-by-side to find your best match.