7.6/10 ScoreToys & Treats

Super Chewer

Tough toys for power chewers

How We Score
Community (Reddit)
6.5/10
Industry Recognition
10/10
Value for Money
6.9/10
Features
7.2/10
Media Coverage
8/10
Trustpilot
4.3/5

Super Chewer by BarkBox is designed specifically for dogs who destroy everything. Each monthly box includes 2 fluff-free, tough toys, 2 full-size bags o...

Price

$29-$45

Founded

2016

Reviews

35,000+

Location

New York, NY

Pros

  • Extremely durable toys
  • Replacement guarantee
  • Great for aggressive chewers
  • Premium treats and chews

Cons

  • Higher price point
  • Limited toy variety
R

What Reddit Says

Based on 20 community discussions

6.5/10
Generally Positive
👍 4
👎 5

"Reddit users have mixed feelings about Super Chewer, with some praising its toy durability and subscription convenience, while others criticize its quality and effectiveness for extreme chewers."

Community Praises

Convenient subscription service for frequent toy replacements

Some toys are durable enough for moderate chewers

Positive experiences with customer service (e.g., gift subscriptions)

Common Complaints

Toys may not withstand extreme chewers, despite claims

Quality concerns (e.g., materials not as advertised)

Mixed reviews on value for the price

What's Included

2 tough toys2 treat bags2 meaty chews

Shipping: Free shipping in USA

Ready to Try Super Chewer?

Visit Super Chewer

Quick Comparison

CompanyPriceScore
Super Chewer$29-$457.6
PupBox$29-$396.3Compare
PupJoy$29-$455.4Compare
RescueBox$29-$395.5Compare

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Super Chewer

Is Super Chewer worth it in 2026?

Super Chewer scored 7.6/10 in our analysis. Key strengths include Extremely durable toys, Replacement guarantee. The main downside is: higher price point. Overall, it's a solid choice for most dog owners.

How much does Super Chewer cost?

Super Chewer costs $29 to $45 per month, depending on your dog's size and subscription length. Longer commitments typically offer better per-month pricing.

What does Super Chewer include?

Each Super Chewer box includes: 2 tough toys, 2 treat bags, 2 meaty chews. Contents may vary by plan and dog size.

What dog sizes does Super Chewer support?

Super Chewer caters to medium, large, all dogs. Toy sizes and treat quantities are adjusted based on your dog's size profile.

Can you cancel Super Chewer?

Yes, you can cancel Super Chewer at any time through your account settings. Monthly plans can be cancelled before the next billing cycle. Multi-month plans may have different cancellation terms.