Updated May 2026
Bullymake vs PupJoy
An in-depth, side-by-side comparison of Bullymake and PupJoy - covering price, quality, community ratings, and which box is best for your dog.
Bullymake is our recommended pick with a score of 6.2/10 and lower starting price
Quick Summary
Bullymake is a monthly dog toys & treats subscription box starting at $27/month, best for power chewers and pit bulls and large breeds.PupJoy is a monthly dog toys & treats subscription box starting at $29/month, best for Picky eaters and Eco-conscious owners.
Overall, Bullymake edges ahead with a composite score of 6.2/10, while PupJoy scores 5.4/10. Both are solid options, but they target different needs.
Bullymake vs PupJoy - Side-by-Side
Pros & Cons
Bullymake
What We Like
- Extremely tough toys
- Made in USA
- Customizable box contents
- Replacement guarantee
What Could Be Better
- Limited theme variety
- Toys only for power chewers
PupJoy
What We Like
- Highly customizable
- Loyalty rewards
- Eco-conscious packaging
What Could Be Better
- Smaller community
- Variable box value
Detailed Score Breakdown
Our Verdict: Bullymake vs PupJoy
After analyzing pricing, features, community feedback, and overall value, Bullymake comes out on top with a score of 6.2/10.
Bullymake stands out for power chewers and pit bulls, while PupJoy is a great alternative if you're looking for Picky eaters or Eco-conscious owners.
Both are reputable services backed by real customer reviews. We recommend trying the monthly plan before committing to a longer subscription.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bullymake or PupJoy better?
Based on our analysis, Bullymake scores higher with 6.2/10 compared to PupJoy's 5.4/10. However, the best choice depends on your dog's needs and your budget.
How much does Bullymake cost compared to PupJoy?
Bullymake costs $27-$39/month, while PupJoy costs $29-$45/month. Bullymake is more affordable at the entry level.
What's included in Bullymake vs PupJoy?
Bullymake is a toys & treats subscription box best for power chewers, pit bulls, large breeds. PupJoy is a toys & treats subscription box best for Picky eaters, Eco-conscious owners.
Can I cancel Bullymake or PupJoy anytime?
Most dog subscription boxes including Bullymake and PupJoy offer monthly plans that can be cancelled anytime. Longer subscription commitments (3, 6, or 12 months) typically offer better per-month pricing but may have different cancellation policies.
What do Reddit users say about Bullymake vs PupJoy?
On Reddit, Bullymake has a community score of 5.5/10 while PupJoy has 6.5/10. We analyze real Reddit discussions to provide unbiased community sentiment alongside our expert analysis.