Ollie vs Surprise Pawty
Side-by-side comparison to help you choose the best box
Ollie scores higher with 8.1/10
| Ollie | Surprise Pawty | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 8.1 | 5.7 |
| Price | $60-$120/mo | $39-$49/mo |
| Box Type | Fresh Food | Toys & Treats |
| Reddit Score | 8 | 6.5 |
| Best For | health conscious, picky eaters, sensitive stomachs | organic treats, eco-conscious owners, premium quality |
| Dog Sizes | small, medium, large, all | small, medium, large |
| Shipping | Free shipping | Free shipping in the US |
Ollie Pros
- ✓ Human-grade ingredients
- ✓ Customized meal plans
- ✓ Pre-portioned servings
- ✓ Visible health improvements
Cons
- ✗ Premium pricing
- ✗ Requires freezer space
Surprise Pawty Pros
- ✓ All-natural organic USA-made treats
- ✓ Portion of sales donated to animal welfare
- ✓ Customized to dog size and preferences
Cons
- ✗ Higher price point
- ✗ Limited plan flexibility
Score Breakdown
Community
8
6.5
Industry
10
10
Value
5.6
5.1
Features
7.2
7.2
Media
10
0
OllieSurprise Pawty