A Pup Above vs GREENIES Club

Side-by-side comparison to help you choose the best box

A Pup Above scores higher with 6.3/10

A Pup AboveGREENIES Club
Score6.34.6
Price$50-$85/mo$20-$40/mo
Box TypeFresh FoodToys & Treats
Reddit Score6
Best Forfresh food, premium diet, health-conscious ownersdental health, oral care, daily treats
Dog Sizessmall, medium, large, allsmall, medium, large
ShippingFree shipping on orders over $50Free shipping on subscriptions

A Pup Above Pros

  • Unique sous-vide cooking
  • Human-grade USDA ingredients
  • No artificial preservatives

Cons

  • Premium pricing
  • Requires freezer space

GREENIES Club Pros

  • Vet recommended dental treats
  • Proven to reduce tartar
  • Auto-delivery convenience
  • Multiple size options

Cons

  • Single product focus
  • Not a variety box

Score Breakdown

Community
6
5
Industry
10
0
Value
6.7
10
Features
6.4
5.6
Media
2
0
A Pup AboveGREENIES Club

A Pup Above

$50-$85/mo

Visit A Pup Above

GREENIES Club

$20-$40/mo

Visit GREENIES Club